r/AskReddit 5d ago

You can have 5000 of anything that starts with Y. What do you choose?

10.1k Upvotes

10.8k comments sorted by

View all comments

711

u/Clever_Mercury 5d ago edited 2d ago

Yttrium-90 microsphere treatments. It's a selective internal radiation therapy (SIRT) that can be used to treat liver cancer and colorectal cancer. It is around $20,000 per dose. One patient may need multiple doses.

Donating 5,000 of these to a few key hospitals could do a lot of good for the world.

Edit: thank you for the award. I don't know how to identify the awarding person under the new Reddit system!

325

u/okaeriiii 5d ago

That's very nice of you. We should have 5000 Yous.

6

u/SeanArthurCox 4d ago

And each of those 5000 yous picks the 5000 Yttrium-90s, so that's 25,000,000 treatments!

2

u/roxgib_ 4d ago

But what if the 5000 Yous creates 5000 more Yous, and eventually the world is crushed under the weight of all the u/Clever_Mercury's created?

5

u/SuperSimpleSam 4d ago

5000 Yous

After reading Dark Matter that might not be a good idea

1

u/Clever_Mercury 2d ago

I know you wrote it a few days ago - but thank you, that comment was very kind of you.

21

u/El_Basho 5d ago

Y-90 has a half-life of just over 2.5 days. Sorry to ruin your altruistic aspirations, but after you treat all eligible patients, most of it would decay to stable and useless material. I appreciate the idea though

11

u/EvilSeraph 4d ago

Is anyone set up to make 5000 doses all at once?  I mean  the question doesn't constrain you to getting the 5000 y-somethings all at once, and if you'd have wait anyway...

4

u/El_Basho 4d ago

Basically they are on-demand only, given its exceptionally short lifespan (at least in the field of radiotherapy). You also need a nuclear reactor to manufacture this material, so that adds to the cost, safety and complexity. It's also a quality assurance nightmare from my perspective

3

u/cs1013 4d ago

Lovely thought, except the hospital is still going to charge full price, maybe more because it’s a ‘special batch’, then bonus their CEO. The insurance companies are going to deny coverage because of the special pricing and the cost will fall to the patient. Then, because there were higher claims made that year (even though they didn’t pay) they raise everyone’s rates and bonus their CEO.

3

u/Sgt_Sarcastic 4d ago

Yeah. The main problem in America at least is that people are only considered worth treating if someone rich benefits from it.

1

u/AnAngryDragon94 4d ago

I hope you have a wonderful day for this wholesome answer

1

u/Serialtorrenter 4d ago

Sweet! That means I could get 5000 Yuengling and get liver cancer 5000 times!

Yippee!

1

u/gravija420 4d ago

This is the best answer I’ve seen to this question so far. I wish there were more compassion and less greed in the world that a $20,000 life potentially life saving medication even exists when I doubt it costs anywhere near that to produce. I worked as a pharmacy technician and the staggering costs of so many medications that I had people turn down picking up because their insurance wouldn’t cover it and they couldn’t afford the hugely overpriced out of pocket costs (I had one elderly man with a $1000 monthly med his insurance had dropped coverage on and he was quite dismayed by the new cost). We live in a world of such abundance and still corporations and pharmaceutical companies want more without giving back anything.

1

u/Ratoara 4d ago

Yeah but 5000 microspheres is like 2 treatments.

1

u/ninjasaid13 4d ago

donating? you could make 100m.

1

u/Throwmeaway20somting 4d ago

I'm glad you said donate, because as a doctor I was about to explain to you how radiation works

1

u/Esmeweatherwaxedlegs 5d ago

You're a saint ❤️

1

u/SymmetricSoles 5d ago

Can't believe I had to scroll this far to find this one.

1

u/MANDALORIAN_WHISKEY 5d ago

You're a beautiful person.

0

u/Shot_Complex 4d ago

That’s a good idea but once donated they prob the patients a lot since that’s what hospitals do